But the greater goodness of Holmes has its limits. Holmes, a privileged logic, has little time for politeness and compassion. Snob, he dismisses the less intelligent, and his attitude towards women ranges from contempt to contempt. Enthusiastic about the game, he often abuses that minor player. In his first novel, The Scarlet Study, he kills Terrier straight. As for Holmes’ best friend, bookstore, and sometimes roommate John Watson, Holmes criticized him, tricked him, disappeared for years, and made Watson believe he was dead. increase.
“It’s terrible to go back and see what it’s like to actually be a close friend of Sherlock Holmes,” said Holmes scholar Ashley Polasek.
Contemporary Clinicians have diagnosed all types of Holmes illnesses, including bipolar disorder, psychopathies, and locations along the autism spectrum. However, it is easy to diagnose the toxic masculinity of the late Victorian era. “It’s just careless about the emotions of those who really should be important to you,” Polacek said. If you’re a hero who treats almost everyone around you, not to mention dogs, how many heroes are you? “
In the last half century, writers and showrunners have questioned Holmes’ habits and attitudes, preparing the way for a drama like “Moriarty” that describes him as a kind of antihero. Besides Meyer’s novels, Michael Dibdin’s pulp-like “Last Sherlock Holmes Story”, John R. Gardner’s Moriarty’s book, the recent BBC series starring Benedict Cumberbatch, manga and anime. There is a series of. “Moriarty the Patriot”
“Almost all of Sherlock’s universe has been done before,” Klinger said in a dry state.
At the same time, efforts have been made to soften Holmes and avoid Holmes, as in King Mary Russell’s novel. Nancy Springer’s Enola Holmes Series, It shifts the focus to my sister. Does this mean that it’s time for Canon’s Holmes? Has the deerstalker become obsolete?